Tuesday, November 11, 2014

Iran's Behavior Causes Question in Motives


The above article outlines a partnership entered between Russia and Iran. As per the deal, Russia will build eight nuclear reactors for the “peaceful use of atomic energy in Iran.” This comes just days after it was revealed that President Obama sent a letter to the Iranian Ayatollah Khamenei offering assistance with the Iranian nuclear program in exchange for aid rallying a force to combat ISIS. Iran is double-dealing with Russia and the United States and may be seeking to attain a nuclear weapon despite claims otherwise.

Though the a copy of the letter has yet to be leaked, the alleged content of the letter has enraged republicans who believe Obama’s approach is the wrong one. Republicans believe that cooperation in the Middle East with ISIS will end in Asaad remaining in power in Syria. Indeed, Asaad’s friendship with Iran is one of the reasons Iran is combating ISIS. While the United States and Iran both want ISIS to be removed from the region, their motives differ. Trading the quicker removal of ISIS for continued rule of Asaad is not worth it according to some politicians.

Further, the announcement of the Russian partnership with Iran comes just one day after the United States promised that Iran would not become a state with a nuclear weapon. Ayatollah Khamenei called for the annihilation of Israel recently. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu continues to claim that Iranian leadership is irrational. Should Iran attain a nuclear weapon and tensions in the region escalate there may not be enough trust between Israel and Iran to prevent war and even possibly the use of a nuclear weapon.

One last strange point in the agreement is that Iran’s spent nuclear fuel would be sent back to Russia for processing and packaging. This could be a way for Iran to enrich nuclear materials for Russia in exchange for a Russian made weapon. Masking the enriched matter as refuse makes it seem innocent on the surface and facilitates movement of nuclear matter between the two countries. If Russia is helping Iran build reactors it should also help Iran manage the waste.


While questions of Iran’s motives are based largely on speculation, double-dealing with the United States and its greatest enemy begs questions of whether or not Iran is to be trusted. The situation is one that will be monitored closely, no doubt, especially if Iran goes through with its deal with Russia.

4 comments:

  1. Matthew: good post. As far as I know this is not the first time the supreme leader has called for the annihilation of Israel. This is a big deal. As I said in my blog post, I believe the US partnership with Iran to defeat ISIL can work. However, I had no idea Russia was in the mix as well. With President Obama and President Putin in China, I can almost feel the tension between them. It will be very interesting to see this play out.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good post dude! This is troublesome. Is Putin supporting Iran as a way to get back at the US for sanctioning Russia? If so, then Gorbachev was right in the sense that we are entering another cold war with Russia. If there is another cold war, are we going to be fighting proxy wars again? Is this going to be an economic war of embargoes and sanctions?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I personally believe that the Russia Ukraine crisis is the reason Putin is talking with Iranian leadership. The enemy of my enemy is my friend definitely applies to this situation. I honestly would not be surprised if proxy wars happen in the somewhat near future.

      Delete
    2. I don't think we are entering another cold war with Russia yet. Yes, tensions are rising but until something drastic happens I think Putin is a rational leader and won't throw his country into trouble.

      Delete